Your water heater can earn money: demand response explained
An electric water heater can earn money by joining a demand response program. Demand response means your utility or a program partner asks your device to use less power during "peak" hours, when the grid is under the most strain. A tank of hot water stores heat for hours, so the heater can warm up early and coast through the peak while you still get hot showers.
Why a water heater works like a battery
A storage water heater is an insulated tank. Once the water is hot, it stays hot for a long time. That makes the tank a "thermal battery": it stores energy as heat instead of electricity.
The grid cares about timing. Power costs the most and is hardest to supply on hot late afternoons and evenings. If the heater does its heating before that window and rests during it, the household uses the same hot water and the grid gets relief when it needs it.
Researchers have tested this for years. In a field study with the Bonneville Power Administration and Northwest utilities, the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) shifted water heaters twice a day using two kinds of signals, as the U.S. Department of Energy reported in 2019:
- A load-up signal turned the water heater on so it reached its set temperature.
- A shed signal turned it off, as long as the household still had hot water.
The same report found that participants used their ability to opt out only 4% of the time.
What an event looks like
An "event" is a window when the program asks your heater to hold off. Each program sets its own rules. Puget Sound Energy's PSE Flex program is a good example because it spells them out on its Flex Water Heaters page:
- PSE can signal enrolled heaters to preheat water or to avoid heating during events.
- Events last two to four hours and fall between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m.
- Water heater events may occur "up to 200 times per year."
- If the water gets too cold during an event, the heater turns back on.
That last point is about comfort. Programs aim to shift when the tank heats, without leaving you in a cold shower. The WatterSaver program in Northern California says the same thing in its own words: if your household needs more hot water during a peak, your water heater "will still respond normally."
You also keep some choice. PSE says customers have the option to decline participating in a Flex event. Opt-out rules differ by program, so read the terms of the one you join.
To see which water heater programs serve your home, check your ZIP at https://civilianpower.com/find.
How a water heater connects to a program
The program has to be able to reach your heater. There are three common ways.
Built-in Wi-Fi. Some newer heat pump and electric models connect to the maker's app over your home Wi-Fi. The program sends its signal through that connection. Support varies by brand: PSE says that, for its program, currently only Rheem brand water heaters are Wi-Fi eligible. The WatterSaver listing on Civilian Power names Rheem, Ruud and Richmond heat pump models.
A CTA-2045 port. CTA-2045 is a standard socket on the water heater that accepts a small plug-in communication module. The Department of Energy describes it as a standard that lets otherwise disconnected devices be connected. Washington State now requires it: under a rule filed in 2026, electric storage water heaters manufactured on or after January 1, 2023 must have a CTA-2045 demand response port.
A utility switch. The oldest method is a small switch the utility installs on the heater's power line. Indiana's consumer advocate explains that a utility-installed switch lets the utility turn off or "cycle" appliances for brief periods during peak demand, and that with some programs these switches go on electric water heaters. A switch works with almost any electric tank, but it can only cut power. It can't tell the heater to warm up early.
Which method you need depends on the program. The water heater page lists programs that accept water heaters and, where we know them, the models they support.
Heat pump vs. electric resistance tanks
Most electric tanks are one of two types.
An electric resistance water heater heats water with metal elements, like a toaster. It is simple and common.
A heat pump water heater (sometimes called a hybrid) pulls heat from the surrounding air and moves it into the water. According to the Department of Energy, heat pump water heaters can be two to three times more efficient than conventional electric-resistance water heaters. Many also include backup resistance elements for times of heavy use.
Both types can do demand response. The differences matter for the grid:
- In the 2019 DOE-reported study, researchers found that 90% of evening peak load power could be reduced by switching from uncontrolled electric resistance water heaters to grid-connected heat pump models. The same report said typical heat pump water heaters can save 60% of annual energy use.
- In lab tests published by PNNL, grid-connected heat pump water heaters reduced peak demand by as much as 0.5 kW, depending on tank size, time of day, control scheme and hot water use.
- The newer CTA-2045-B version allows an "advanced" load-up above the normal set temperature. In that same PNNL work, a prototype raised tank temperature by 15°F, adding 1.8 kWh of storage for a 50-gallon tank.
A resistance tank uses more power while it heats, so shifting it moves more load per event. A heat pump tank uses less energy all year. Some programs accept both. PSE Flex says both electric resistance and heat pump tank models qualify, and tankless units do not.
How water heater programs pay
Payment structures vary. The common types are:
- Enrollment bonus. A one-time payment for signing up.
- Ongoing reward. A monthly or yearly amount for staying enrolled.
- Bill credit. A credit on your utility bill. Indiana's consumer advocate notes that with investor-owned utilities there, switch participants receive a bill credit whether or not the appliance is cycled.
- Capacity or performance payments. Paid to a provider that groups many homes together, which then shares them under its own terms.
Here is what two programs say they pay:
- WatterSaver: a one-time $50 enrollment bonus and a $5 monthly reward.
- PSE Flex Water Heaters: $20 upon enrolling, plus $20 each year you stay enrolled.
Water heater power payback programs
These programs in the Civilian Power directory list water heaters. Availability depends on your utility.
California power payback programs
- WatterSaver: for PG&E customers with a smart electric resistance or heat pump water heater. The program says it is administered through PG&E and implemented by the Association for Energy Affordability. Gas and tankless heaters don't qualify.
- CA Demand Side Grid Support (DSGS): a California Energy Commission program that runs during extreme events from May to October. Customers take part through a provider, such as a third-party load flexibility provider, rather than signing up with the state.
More programs: California market page.
Washington power payback programs
- PSE Flex: Puget Sound Energy's program for electric tank water heaters that can communicate with PSE, along with thermostats, EV chargers and batteries.
More programs: Washington market page.
Nebraska power payback programs
- Southern Public Power District Water Heater Load Management: Southern Public Power District offers a Marathon water heater program for customers converting from natural gas or propane, or replacing an existing water heater. Contact the district for current control and credit terms.
More programs: Nebraska market page.
Before you enroll
Programs and device makers control the equipment, under their own terms. Before you sign up, check three things: that your heater model is on the program's list, how the program connects to it, and how you opt out of an event or leave the program.
Find the water heater programs that serve your address by checking your ZIP at https://civilianpower.com/find.
Sources
- "Heat Pump Water Heaters Achieve Significant Peak Reduction and Energy Savings," U.S. Department of Energy, Building Technologies Office, 2019. https://www.energy.gov/cmei/buildings/articles/heat-pump-water-heaters-achieve-significant-peak-reduction-and-energy
- "Water Heaters Heat Pumps," Building Science Education, U.S. Department of Energy. https://bsesc.energy.gov/energy-basics/water-heaters-heat-pumps
- K.E. Fenaughty, D. Parker, J.B. Butzbaugh, "Detailed Evaluation of Electric Demand Load-Shifting Potential of Heat Pump Water Heaters," Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 2022 (posted 2023). https://www.pnnl.gov/publications/detailed-evaluation-electric-demand-load-shifting-potential-heat-pump-water-heaters
- WSR 26-05-066, Washington State Department of Commerce, Washington State Register, 2026. https://lawfilesext.leg.wa.gov/Law/WSR/2026/05/26-05-066.htm
- "A Small Switch," Indiana Office of Utility Consumer Counselor, 2019. https://www.in.gov/oucc/electric/tips-and-publications/a-small-switch
- "Flex Water Heaters," Puget Sound Energy, accessed 2026. https://www.pse.com/en/rebates/PSE-flex/flex-water-heaters
- "PSE Flex," Puget Sound Energy, accessed 2026. https://www.pse.com/en/rebates/PSE-flex
- "How It Works," WatterSaver, accessed 2026. https://www.watter-saver.com/how-it-works/
- "Demand Side Grid Support Program," California Energy Commission, accessed 2026. https://www.energy.ca.gov/programs-and-topics/programs/demand-side-grid-support-program
- "DSGS Program," Demand Side Grid Support program site (Olivine), accessed 2026. https://dsgs.olivineinc.com/
- "Electric Water Heater Program," Southern Public Power District, accessed 2026. https://southernpd.com/electric-water-heater-program/
Check if your address qualifies
Programs depend on your utility and where you live. Enter your ZIP code to see every program that pays in your area.